Elsie Mae’s Products
Select products sold in-store at the Sweet Shop, Sugar & Vice, and Peninsula Pies.
Also sold seasonally at Farmer’s Markets and in select retail partners including Woodman’s.
Pies
Handcrafted with all-butter crusts and Wisconsin-sourced fruit whenever possible. Available fresh baked and frozen in three sizes. Gluten-free pies available.
Full Size (9″) — approximately 8 slices
Mini Pies (5″) — approximately 2 slices
Cutie Pies (3″) — individual servings
Popular Pie Flavors Include:
Dutch Apple
Traditional Apple
Blueberry
Buckeye (Chocolate pie with peanut butter fudge and chocolate ganache)
Caramel Apple
Cherry
Cherry Almond
Cherry Apricot
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan
French Silk
Key Lime
Nutella
Oreo
Peanut Butter Cream
Dutch Peach
Traditional Peach
Pecan
Pumpkin
Raspberry Key Lime
Raspberry Peach
S’mores
Strawberry Rhubarb
Wisconsin Berry (Strawberry, blueberry, raspberry, blackberry and cranberry)
Seasonal and holiday varieties rotate throughout the year including specials for Valentine’s Day, Easter, Thanksgiving, and more
Pot Pies & Quiches
Our pot pies are very popular, especially in the fall and winter when a variety of flavors are offered. Why did we start serving them? Due to a frost and drought during a previous growing season, Kelly was low on fruit for pies so she created pot pies for the crowd.
Full Size (9″) — approximately 8 slices
Mini Pies (5″) — approximately 2 slices
Cutie Pies (3″) — individual servings
Pot Pie Flavors:
Chicken Alfredo
Traditional Chicken
Meatball
Shepherd’s
Pork and Apple
Vegetarian Wild Rice and Mushroom
Wild Rice and Mushroom with Chicken
Quiche Flavors:
Bacon and Blue
Ham and Cheddar
Pesto
Spinach and Feta
Sun-dried Tomato and Feta
Seasonal varieties rotate throughout the year including Reuben, Tamale, and more.
Artisan Breads, Turnovers, and Croissants
Baked fresh in-store on Saturdays. Plain, filled, seasonal flavors, and more.
Donuts
Baked fresh in-store on Sundays. Variety of flavors available.
Homemade Jams
Made once per season from fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
Organized into seasonal collections:
Spring, Summer, Fall, Dessert, Strawberry, and Cranberry.
Past and recurring flavors include:
Apricot
Autumn Pear
Blueberry
Caramel Apple
Carrot Cake
Cherry Rhubarb
Chocolate Cranberry Peppermint
Fig
Gingered Asian Pear
Strawberry
Very Cherry Berry
Wisconsin Berry
When a batch is gone it’s gone until next season.
Canned Bloody Marys
Made in collaboration with Last Ditch Brew Pub, Kenosha, WI.
Seasonal and rotating flavors released throughout the year. Current varieties include:
The Original — Classic, Medium Hot
Hot Lips Habanero — Pureed habaneros, fresh lime, garlic, and savory spice
Tomatillo Verde — Tomatillos, lime, cilantro, and jalapeño
Bunny Mary — Carrot juice, honey, and ancho chili
Craft Hard Lemonades
Made in collaboration with Last Ditch Brew Pub, Kenosha, WI.
Seasonal and rotating flavors released throughout the year. Current varieties include:
Cherry
Blueberry
Strawberry
Blackberry
Raspberry
Bloody Mary Mixes
Award-winning bloody mary mixes. Just add vodka.
Seasonal and rotating flavors released throughout the year. Current varieties include:
The Original — Classic, Medium Hot
Hot Lips Habanero — Pureed habaneros, fresh lime, garlic, and savory spice
Tomatillo Verde — Tomatillos, lime, cilantro, and jalapeño
Bunny Mary — Carrot juice, honey, and ancho chili
Cocktail Mixes & Lemonade Concentrates
Elsie Mae’s Wisconsin-made cocktail mixes. Just add your spirit of choice. Just add water to our lemonade concentrates for a perfect refreshing drink. Or add your favorite spirit to make it a cocktail!
Seasonal and rotating flavors released throughout the year.
Current cocktail mix options include:
Margarita
Raspberry Margarita
Wisconsin Old Fashioned
Hurricane
Mai Tai
Paloma
Current lemonade concentrate flavors include:
Strawberry
Blueberry
Cherry
Peach
Raspberry
Blackberry
Elderberry
Prickly Pear
Where to Purchase
- Elsie Mae’s Sweet Shop: 360 Enterprise Drive, Lake Mills, WI
- Sugar & Vice at Last Ditch Brew Pub: 6521 120th Ave, Kenosha, WI
- Elsie Mae’s Peninsula Pies: 8813 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI
- Woodman’s : Kenosha, Racine, Oak Creek, WI and Lakemoor, IL
- The Brat Stop: Kenosha, WI
- 40+ farmers markets across the Chicago and Milwaukee areas — Check our event schedule
Ready to Taste It for Yourself?
All products are available in person at our locations and at farmers markets throughout the season. Follow us on Facebook for upcoming events and specials!